Talk:TIE Phantom Expansion Pack/@comment-2602:306:8BF8:FD0:E003:5009:B092:DD4C-20180110020201/@comment-454133-20180110021520

Imperial Kath Scarlet doesn't share a pilot ability with Whisper... do you mean something else by "Captain Skill", like Pilot Skill? The comparison of a TIE Phantom to a Firespray is far more complicated than that (the phantom's cost has to do with its actions, maneuvers, everything; the Firespray cannot cloak, for example). And you should know that the firespray rarely hits the table these days anyway; it too is overcosted. It's been a long time since I saw Imperial Kath used even in a jank list, and I was the one using it.

Yes the TIE Phantom is too delicate for its cost; Whisper's time in the top meta came and went, thanks to new ships and upgrades making it hard to win the PS and arc wars. Such is often the fate of top-meta builds -- just ask swarm players, T-65 fans, etc. I like the TIE Phantom and I'm sad to not see it perform well anymore.