Talk:First Order Vanguard/@comment-31.159.75.35-20171127153603/@comment-29680667-20171213154212

A reroll is different than a roll. They are different keywords in X-wing, so Palpatine cannot be used to change a reroll. It happens after the roll, not after the reroll. I always thought that Palpatine took effect in step 2 of the timing chart for attacks (similar to how Heavy Laser Cannon does). That would mean Palpatine's effect is done before you get to the modify attack dice step. I think the key is that Palpatine says "after rolling" and not that you change it in the "Modify Dice Step". Maybe someone will chime in to clarify, please!

I think b is the correct option.

A similar but less extreme example is if your opponent has Zuckuss. If Zuckuss forces a reroll of some defense dice, normally you can only reroll a die one time. So here, we are again debating between b and c. I would play as b is the correct option, you only reroll the dice that Zuckuss did not have you reroll. But I do see your point that perhaps since you cannot reroll all your defense dice you would be prevented from using the title's effect.