Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26501522-20150817203509/@comment-454133-20161016072220

I'm ambivalent. It might work better as a category, though. Then anyone interested can click that category and see a list of all the pages for cards that person drew. And the list of categories is pretty compact at the bottom (and easy to edit).

My main opinion on clutter is pretty overly lax (and I realize I'm on the extreme end of things): I only intervene to remove info or reorganize it when it's becoming a real problem, and I prefer to try to work it in cleanly instead of removing (assuming it's accurate and arguably relevant and useful info).

Rather than seeing this as a valid counter-argument, keep in mind I'm pretty extremely lax. This is entirely personal, but some background on why I'm generally ambivalent or approving of adding info: My first Wikia editing experience was the Minecraft Tekkit Wiki some years ago. Back then the moderators would regularly make sweeping reverts of nearly all changes, for the most bizarre (and controlling) reasons, and their extreme lawful-evil alignment left their mark on me. (long story omitted, can share if anyone's interested)  And that was my first Wikia editing experience. :D  So I'm overly gun-shy about even telling anyone "don't add that info, it's cluttered", likely to a fault (and others here should probably balance my stance with basic rules -- do push back!). I keep wanting to encourage people to add info without fears of their efforts being wasted, even though I worry about them cluttering things up a bit. And eventually we will have to go in and make adjustments, just because it happens, and that does create extra work for the regulars who care about how things look and feel and work here. So uh... I have super-baggage in this area. :D

True story: Because of my Tekkit experiences, I was sweating bullets when I built the Compare Ship pages, expecting someone to revert all that work in one fell swoop and tell me to not do that again. True I was pretty sure other wikia sites were not like Tekkit had been, but I was genuinely relieved and delighted when people told me they loved the pages and were using them, instead of "GTFO noob this is wrong and you're wrong".

So when I tell people "you're fine!  keep adding info!" you may want to push back and set some stronger boundaries. :D  I'm actually in favor of keeping things clean, but I'm always over-correcting in the other direction, just in case.